Vol. XII  ·  No. 47

Printed at Undertowers, in the Westmarch

Price: One Penny, or a Half-pound of Leaf

Book notices, warnings & enthusiasms from the far side of the Shire

Highday, 24th Afterlithe, S.R. 1426

Weekly, weather and appetite permitting

Eleven pages, one of them advertisements

Front Page › Reviews

Every Notice, Newest First

Subscribe by RSS

6 notices to date. Books not finished are listed but never rated — see the Larder Scale for why.

A Doorstop, Defended

Rated 5 of 6 meals.5 meals  ·  Supper can wait

Fourteen volumes, a middle that sits down for a rest, and an ending that earns every page of the walk. An honest accounting of the cost before the recommendation.

The House That Eats Its Heir

Rated 4 of 6 meals.4 meals  ·  Stayed up later than sensible

The castle is the character; everyone inside it is furniture with opinions. Read it slowly or not at all.

Statues, Halls, an Ocean Indoors

Rated 6 of 6 meals.6 meals  ·  Cold supper, no regrets

I have kept this notice useless on purpose. Go in knowing nothing, and I would do it again.

A Wizard, Badly Behaved

Rated 5 of 6 meals.5 meals  ·  A spare copy, for lending

A boy is clever, the cleverness costs him, and the rest of the book is the bill arriving. Nothing wasted anywhere in it.

Court Manners for the Friendless

Rated 4 of 6 meals.4 meals  ·  I have told someone about it

An unwanted heir inherits, and is decent about it, and decency turns out to be the hardest thing in the room.

The Book I Keep Restarting

Rated 3 of 6 meals.3 meals  ·  Provisional

The narrator is lying and the prose is gorgeous and I cannot tell which of those is the obstacle.

Have the Review delivered

One issue a week, on Highday morning. Three or four notices, whatever I've abandoned, and nothing else. No post on weeks I've only been rereading.